Would I personally give it 5 stars, not really....but I am basing the star rating on the fixation my cats have formed for it. Leaping from across the house to spring on it, tells me they like it alot. Not to mention the missing feathers, casualties of aggressive playing. for the price I think this was a great purchase.....but who am I to say. Let's take it from the real experts...as i hear the jiggling of collars mounting speed and pounce...yes I do believe they would highly recommend this to all their fellow felines.